
A buyer in Roseville or Rocklin hears two stories about California housing at once. One says sellers are cutting prices and paying buyers' costs. The other says homes in the right neighborhood still draw multiple offers. Both are true, and the gap between them decides how much a buyer can ask for.
The national shift toward buyers is real, and it reaches California. The skill is in reading which market a particular house sits in, and then deciding whether to ask for a lower price, a closing cost credit or help with the rate.
Sellers are giving more ground than they have in years
Redfin estimated there were 62.6% more home sellers than buyers in the U.S. in September, the widest gap in records that go back to 2013. Sellers have answered with money. In August, 44.7% of U.S. home sales included a seller concession, up from 42.6% a year earlier, and 15.8% came with both a price cut and a concession.
In the four weeks ending October 11, a record 22% of active listings had a price cut, and the typical home took 49 days to go under contract. With purchase applications running 18% behind last year's pace in early November, according to Fortune, a seller who needs to close usually has to offer something.
A $10,000 price cut lowers your payment less than you think
Most buyers ask for a lower price first, because the price is the number everyone sees. The monthly payment tells a different story. In a worked example from Yahoo Finance on a $400,000 home with a $320,000 loan, a $10,000 price cut saved about $70 a month. The same $10,000 spent on a permanent rate buydown saved about $135 a month, and spent on a 2-1 buydown it saved $418 a month in the first year.
A price cut trims the loan balance, and that saving is spread across decades of payments. A buydown goes straight at the interest rate, which is the heaviest part of the payment with 30-year rates above 7% in early November.
A seller credit can pay closing costs or buy down your rate, and you choose which
A seller concession is money the seller puts toward the buyer's costs at closing, not cash in hand. It can cover lender fees, title charges, prepaid taxes and insurance, or discount points that lower the rate, and the offer decides where it goes.
A buyer who has the down payment but little cash left for closing usually gets more from a closing cost credit. A buyer with cash who worries about the monthly bill may get more from points, which lower the rate for the life of the loan. A temporary buydown lowers it for only a year or two.
Every loan program caps what the seller can pay
The loan sets a ceiling on seller help. For a conventional loan on a home the buyer will live in, Fannie Mae caps seller contributions at 3% of the price when the loan is more than 90% of the value, 6% between 75.01% and 90%, and 9% at 75% or less. On an investment property the cap is 2%.
FHA allows up to 6% of the sales price. VA caps seller concessions at 4% of reasonable value but leaves normal closing costs and discount points out of that count, while a seller-funded temporary buydown counts. Money above any cap never comes back as cash.
A 2-1 buydown is a two-year discount, and you qualify at the full rate
A 2-1 buydown lowers the rate by two percentage points in year one and one point in year two, then the full note rate applies. The seller pays the difference up front, and it is held to cover the gap each month.
The discount does not help anyone qualify. Fannie Mae requires the lender to qualify the borrower at the note rate, which protects the buyer, because the year-three payment is the real one. In an illustration with a $320,000 loan and an assumed 7% note rate, principal and interest come to about $1,718 a month in year one, $1,919 in year two and $2,129 from year three on, at a cost to the seller of about $7,459. A 2-1 suits a buyer who can carry the full payment today and wants a cushion, not one counting on a future refinance.
A price cut still wins in some cases
A lower price means a smaller loan for its whole life, and it can shrink the down payment when that is figured as a share of the price. In some places a lower recorded price also feeds into a lower property tax assessment. Points take years to earn back, and part of that money is lost if the buyer sells or refinances early.
Some buyers ask the seller to raise the price and credit the difference back at closing. That works only if the appraisal supports the higher price. If the home appraises lower, the lender uses the lower number.
California is two markets, and the ask depends on which one you are in
In September, 22.8% of listings in the West had a price cut, the highest share of any region, according to Realtor.com data reported by National Mortgage News. Yet in San Jose, only 4.2% of August sales included a seller concession, near the bottom of the large metros Redfin tracks. One commenter on a YouTube video about the topic put it plainly: "There is a huge shortage of all housing in my part of California so it's not quite that simple."
In the Sacramento region, including Placer County, the evidence is the house itself. A home that has sat for weeks or already had a price cut is a fair candidate for a credit request. A fresh listing in a tight neighborhood may not be. Either way, a request works better when it names an amount, says what the money pays for and fits the loan's limit.
Common questions
Should I ask the seller for closing costs or a lower price?
It depends on what is short. If cash at closing is the problem, a closing cost credit helps most. If the monthly payment is the problem, have a lender price points, a temporary buydown and a price cut on the actual house, in writing, before the offer goes in.
Is it a buyer's market in California?
It depends on the city and the price range. The West had the highest share of price cuts in September, while San Jose ranked near the bottom of large metros for seller concessions in August.
This week, check the listing history of any home you are considering: days on market and every price change. That history, more than any headline, tells you how much to ask for.
Amy DeBusk Home Loans can price the options on a specific house at amydebuskhomeloans.com.
This post is general education, not a loan offer. Amy DeBusk Home Loans. Amy DeBusk, NMLS 281056. loanDepot.com, LLC, NMLS 174457. Equal Housing Opportunity.
All Mortgage Made Easy articles · Book a Complimentary Discovery Call · Call (916) 705-2557. NMLS 281056.