Roseville, CA · NMLS 281056 · Licensed CA, TN, TX (916) 705-2557 adebusk@loandepot.com

Research & policy · November 2026

Restoring the
American Dream

America’s Housing Shortage and the First-Time Homebuyer Crisis

Understand why homes are in short supply and what the opportunity to own could mean for your future. Amy DeBusk explores how homeownership can build equity and long-term wealth, and how first-time buyers can turn that possibility into a plan.

62 pages · PDF · Revised November 14, 2026

Cover of Amy DeBusk’s research report, America’s Housing Shortage and the First-Time Homebuyer Crisis, November 2026

The complete report: Restoring the American Dream: The Long Line at the Front Door.

Warm sunset light over a neighborhood of homes, trees, and a community park
So many front doors.
Still not enough within reach.A neighborhood. A community. A place to belong.

The big picture · Updated evidence

Millions of homes short.
Millions of dreams on hold.

4.03 millionEstimated U.S. housing supply gap in 2025.

Source: Realtor.com, 2026 Housing Supply Gap Report · March 3, 2026.

The challenge is not just building more homes. It is helping families find one they can afford and keep.

About the estimate and the report

This national estimate includes people who might have formed their own households but are still living with parents, relatives, or roommates. Local conditions vary; a national shortage does not mean every neighborhood has too few listings. The neighborhood photograph is illustrative; it does not measure the shortage in that community.

The report cites Freddie Mac’s estimate of 3.7 million homes for Q3 2024. Realtor.com uses a different method, so the figures are not a measure of growth from 3.7 to 4.03 million. The original report and PDF retain their cited figures.

Freddie Mac · November 26, 2024 →
Amy DeBusk, author of Restoring the American Dream, wearing a pale pink blazer

Understand the shortage. See the opportunity.

Amy DeBusk

Branch Manager & Mortgage Advisor · NMLS 281056

“I wrote this research to help first-time buyers understand the housing shortage and recognize the opportunity homeownership can offer. Building equity in a home of your own can be a powerful path to long-term wealth. I want buyers to see that possibility clearly and pursue the American Dream with knowledge, confidence, and a plan.”

Meet Amy →
A close aerial view of homes surrounded by leafy green trees and neighborhood streets

A path to a place of your own

How do we make homeownership possible for more families?

Build more homes people can afford. Help first-time buyers get through the door. Make sure the costs leave room for life after move-in.

Explore the four topics ↓

What the research explores

What stands between
a family and a home?

Finding a home. Paying for it. Feeling ready to buy. Managing the costs after move-in. These four topics connect the housing crisis to the decisions families face.

Workers building a two-story home in warm daylight01

Not enough homes to buy

Years of underbuilding and fewer homeowners selling have left buyers with limited choices. The paper examines why we need more homes, especially homes first-time buyers can afford.

Why homes are in short supply →
A smiling young couple holding up a key to a home02

The cost of a first home

Saving the down payment is only part of the challenge. Home prices, mortgage costs, and assistance programs all affect whether a first-time buyer can make the purchase work.

What helps buyers afford a home →
A young couple talking together at a table with financial paperwork03

The fear inherited from 2008

Watching your parents lose their home can leave a lasting question: “What if that happens to me?” The paper explores how family experiences of foreclosure may shape the next generation’s trust in mortgages and confidence in buying.

How a parent’s loss can shape a buyer’s fears →
AI-created illustration of a young couple painting the outside of a starter home, showing its roof, front door, windows, porch, and yard04
AI-created illustration

Life after getting the keys

Owning a home means planning for more than the mortgage. Repairs, savings, and everyday expenses matter too. The paper looks at what helps families enjoy their home while staying financially secure.

Making room for life after buying →

See the evidence

What the numbers mean
for the people behind them.

Who already owns a home? Why can assistance still fall short? How much does a rate change affect a payment? Each view answers a different part of the housing question.

Who already owns a home · 2025 Census data

Homeownership in 2025

How many households own the home they live in? Compare the United States, California, and Placer County using the same 2025 survey.

  • United States65.3%
  • California55.7%
  • Placer County74.0%
2025 American Community Survey · One-year estimates · Bars share a 0%-100% scale.
A high ownership rate tells us who already owns a home. It does not tell us whether a first-time buyer can afford one today. Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2025 ACS, Table B25003: Tenure, released October 29, 2026. Checked November 14, 2026.
See the counts and how the chart was calculated

Owner-occupied homes divided by all occupied homes, multiplied by 100 and rounded to one decimal place. Vacant homes are not in the denominator.

  • United States: 87,511,734 owner-occupied homes out of 134,063,422 occupied homes.
  • California: 7,739,255 owner-occupied homes out of 13,898,622 occupied homes.
  • Placer County: 124,625 owner-occupied homes out of 168,401 occupied homes.

These are survey estimates with sampling uncertainty. This website chart now uses 2025 one-year estimates. The original report’s page 12 retains its 2020-2024 five-year comparison; the two products should not be treated as a year-to-year trend.

When the program rules don’t match the home prices

Eligible for help.
Still unable to buy.

A buyer can meet a program’s income limit and still earn too little to qualify for a suitable home in that area. Another buyer earns just over the limit, loses access to the benefit, and still struggles with the payment. This is the gap Amy repeatedly encounters in her work as a mortgage advisor.

Homes and tree-lined front yards in an established Folsom, California neighborhood
The goal is a home within reach, not simply a program you qualify for.

HomeReady & Home Possible

Earn a little more.
Lose help you still need.

HomeReady and Home Possible generally limit qualifying income to 80% of the area median income. Eligible buyers may receive better loan pricing and lower mortgage-insurance costs. Earn just above the cutoff, and you may lose that help while still struggling to afford a local home.

Homes along a tree-lined street with golden autumn leaves and front gardens
The income limit needs to fit the cost of a home.

Too much incometo meet the program’s limit

Still not enoughto comfortably afford the home

HomeReady and Home Possible are first-mortgage products, not stand-alone down payment grants. Their income limits were updated in June 2026; the issue is whether the limits fit local buying costs, rather than whether they are never updated. Other loan options and first-time-buyer pricing waivers may still apply. Rates and savings depend on the actual loan. HomeReady rules · Home Possible rules · Fannie Mae’s 2026 update · Freddie Mac’s 2026 update

A couple sitting together on the front steps of a home
Make a plan for both the down payment and the cost of closing.

Where CalHFA MyHome can work

Help with the down payment.
A plan for the closing costs.

Explore our CalHFA assistance options →

MyHome can make a purchase possible when the monthly payment works but the buyer needs help with upfront cash. Its county income limits reach more working households: the 2026 limit is $245,000 in Placer and Sacramento counties. Dream For All uses separate limits.

Up to 3%MyHome assistance with conventional financing
Up to 3.5%MyHome assistance with FHA financing
No monthly
DPA installment
MyHome payments are deferred; interest accrues and repayment comes later.

Down payment assistance does not automatically cover the whole cost of closing. When a loan estimate includes a 2% borrower-paid origination charge, that fee sits alongside other loan costs, escrow and title charges, insurance, and prepaid items. The 2% is an example of lender pricing, not a mandatory CalHFA fee for every borrower.

A seller credit can make the difference.

When the seller agrees to cover eligible closing costs, MyHome can help with the down payment while the credit helps with the cost of getting the loan closed. This combination is one Amy uses to help buyers move forward. The buyer may still need funds for remaining expenses.

FHA: up to 6%of the sales price toward eligible costs
Low-down-payment conventional: up to 3%of the lower of sales price or appraised value, for a primary home with loan-to-value above 90%

Seller credits cannot exceed eligible actual costs, replace the required down payment, or become cash back to the buyer. The seller has to agree, and the final amount must fit the loan’s rules.

Program terms and sources

MyHome assistance is based on the lower of the price or appraised value. It is an interest-bearing loan, not a grant. Principal and accrued interest become due under its terms, including sale, transfer, refinance, or payoff of the first mortgage. Other assistance programs also defer payments. Lender fees and available programs vary.

MyHome overview · Repayment terms · 2026 income limits · Allowable lender fees · FHA credit limits · Conventional credit limits

Homes along a neighborhood street in West RosevillePlacer County, California

The local example

The assistance was there.
The buying power wasn’t.

Placer County staff said the former $100,000 assistance cap was not enough for many eligible households. Home prices, borrowing costs, insurance, and limited eligible homes still stood in the way.

109Applications processed
13Households fully approved
with a prequalified lender

County snapshot, February 17, 2026. These are application and approval counts, not completed purchases or a rejection rate. Read the county’s findings. Neighborhood photograph is illustrative.

Results across California assistance programs

How many households did the help reach?

CalHFA’s reported households served in fiscal year 2025-26, from its September 17, 2026 board presentation.

Households served · Shared 0-6,000 scale · Counts rounded to the nearest 100.
Source: CalHFA FY 2025-26 program outcomes, slides 13-14. ZIP and MyAccess are paired with MyHome, so these bars overlap and must not be added together as separate families. Dream For All figures are preliminary and subject to reporting updates. These statewide results use a different measure and period from Placer County’s application snapshot; they do not establish approval rates or how many eligible buyers remained unserved.

California Dream For All

Meaningful help for a family.
Limited reach across a state.

Explore our Dream For All guide →

Dream For All can provide substantial assistance, but meeting the rules does not guarantee funding. All borrowers must be first-time buyers, at least one must meet the first-generation requirement, and county income limits apply. The 2026 round used randomized voucher selection.

The program provides a shared-appreciation loan of up to 20% of the purchase price, capped at $150,000. The loan and a share of appreciation must be repaid under the program’s terms. It is not a free grant.

Read CalHFA’s program requirements →

Homes, winding streets, and colorful autumn trees in a leafy neighborhood
Helping more families find a place to call home.
About 1,200Dream For All households served
FY 2025-26 · Preliminary, rounded

CalHFA reported 1,732 home purchases in FY 2024-25. The number varies by funding round and year; it is not a fixed 1,000-family annual allotment.

2024-25 annual results →

The question every program should answer: After the assistance is applied, can an eligible buyer actually afford a suitable home in that community?

Read the research on assistance and affordability →
What a rate change means · The full monthly payment

A half-point change matters.
So does the rest of the payment.

Each bar includes the mortgage, property taxes, homeowners insurance, and PMI. The amount at the right is the full monthly total for this example.

$450,000 home$50,000 down (11.1%)$400,000 conventional loan · 30-year fixed

  • Principal & interest: varies by rate
  • Property taxes: $469/mo
  • Homeowners insurance: $150/mo
  • PMI: $167/mo
  • 6.00% rate$3,184/month
  • 6.50% rate$3,314/month
  • 7.00% rate$3,447/month
  • 7.50% rate$3,582/month
Shared $0-$4,000 monthly scale. Displayed totals are rounded to the nearest dollar.

At 6.50%, the full payment is about $3,314/month. At 7.00%, it is about $3,447/month: a difference of $133/month.

See the full breakdown and example assumptions
Estimated monthly payment by rate
RatePrincipal & interestProperty taxesHomeowners insurancePMIFull payment
6.00%$2,398.20$468.75$150.00$166.67$3,183.62
6.50%$2,528.27$468.75$150.00$166.67$3,313.69
7.00%$2,661.21$468.75$150.00$166.67$3,446.63
7.50%$2,796.86$468.75$150.00$166.67$3,582.27

Illustrative inputs: annual property taxes at 1.25% of the $450,000 price ($5,625.00/year), homeowners insurance at $1,800/year, and borrower-paid PMI at 0.50% of the original loan annually. PMI is included because this conventional example has less than 20% down. The PMI amount is an assumption, not an insurer quote.

Taxes, insurance, and PMI are held constant here to isolate the effect of changing the mortgage rate; actual costs depend on the property, coverage, credit, and loan terms. HOA dues are assumed to be $0; add them where applicable. Repairs and utilities belong in the household budget separately. FHA uses a different mortgage-insurance structure.

Calculated for this website illustration; not a loan quote. What belongs in a full mortgage payment?
Amy DeBusk at the loanDepot office beside a sign about the American Dream of homeownership

“With America short more than four million homes, why aren’t more first-time buyers asking, ‘What would it take for me to qualify?’

In a world chasing wealth, homeownership whispers stability. A place of your own. Equity built over time. The possibility of lasting wealth. That opportunity deserves a closer look.”

Amy DeBusk Author · Mortgage Advisor

The complete research

Read the full report.

America’s Housing Shortage and the First-Time Homebuyer Crisis
Restoring the American Dream: The Long Line at the Front Door

Read all 12 chapters online, or download the complete report to save, print, and share.

Start Reading Online →

Download the Full Report ↓

Open the PDF in a new tab →

Author
Amy DeBusk
Edition
November 2026
Length & format
62 pages · PDF · Revised November 14, 2026

The complete online edition

Follow the question
that brought you here.

Begin with Chapter 1 or go straight to the topic that interests you. Every section has its own address, source links, and a path to continue reading.

A young couple celebrating with a house keyStart here · Chapter 1

Generations Arriving at the Front Door

Begin the report with the people seeking a home and the generations shaping demand. Read Chapter 1 →

Jump to a page on the report 1-59 + 37A-37C

The online edition groups several PDF pages into each chapter. Select a page to open its place in the web edition. Pages 1 and 2 correspond to the cover and contents on the research home page. The revised PDF adds Chapter 7 pages 37A-37C while retaining all original page numbers.

Population by age chart from the research paperChapter 01

Generations Arriving at the Front Door

Why so many first-time buyers are still waiting for a home of their own.

Read chapter →
A new home under constructionChapter 02

The Homes We Didn’t Build

Follow the construction recovery, the shortage of attainable ownership options, and the local delivery pipeline.

Read chapter →
Rows of homes along California’s coastChapter 03

What’s Keeping Homes Off the Market?

Explore mortgage lock-in, aging in place, institutional ownership, and the limits of proposed mobility reforms.

Read chapter →
Illustrative rent-versus-buy wealth comparison from the reportChapter 04

What Homeownership Can Give You, and What It Can Cost

Read the tradeoffs behind equity, leverage, transaction costs, and the decision to rent or buy.

Read chapter →
A household budget with a calculator and notebookChapter 05

Can You Afford the Payment and Still Enjoy Your Life?

Connect mortgage costs to the expenses, reserves, and choices that shape everyday life.

Read chapter →
A young couple holding a house keyChapter 06

Why Down Payment Help Doesn’t Always Open the Door

See why the right subsidy, eligible inventory, and financeable payment have to meet in the same transaction.

Read chapter →
Chart comparing mortgage payments at different interest ratesChapter 07

What Really Goes Into Your Mortgage Costs?

Examine pricing waivers, insurance, income thresholds, and the cost of the complete loan.

Read chapter →
People reviewing financial reports and market informationChapter 08

Jobs Reports and Mortgage Rates: What’s the Connection?

Separate what economic-data revisions show from what they cannot establish about borrower costs.

Read chapter →
A couple talking through financial decisionsChapter 09

How Family Wealth and Past Losses Shape Homebuying

Consider family resources, mortgage distress, and the experiences that influence ownership decisions.

Read chapter →
Grandparents and a child together at homeChapter 10

Buying a Home Together as a Family

Read the opportunities and shared obligations that come with combining family income and resources.

Read chapter →
Comparison of six household scenarios from the reportChapter 11

Six Household Examples: What Makes Buying Possible?

Work through six illustrative households, overlapping policy changes, and financial stress tests.

Read chapter →
Sacramento’s Tower Bridge in warm sunlightChapter 12

A Practical Plan to Help More People Become Homeowners

Explore proposals for attainable supply, assistance, pricing, mobility, education, and public accountability.

Read chapter →

Connect the research to your next step

What could homeownership look like for you?

Explore the practical tools alongside the research. Your own spending plan, timeline, and goals belong at the center of the decision.

Your questions, answered

Real questions about buying your first home.

The numbers tell part of the story. These are the questions that help you decide what they mean for you.

01Does a shortage of four million homes mean prices will keep going up?

No. The 4.03 million figure is Realtor.com’s estimate of the national housing supply gap in 2025, not a forecast for any particular home. Local inventory, jobs, mortgage rates, and buyer budgets all matter. The opportunity is worth understanding, but the purchase still needs to fit your finances and timeline. Explore the housing shortage.

02How can owning a home help me build long-term wealth?

As you repay mortgage principal, you build equity in the home. If its value rises, that can add equity too. Your result also depends on interest, maintenance, taxes, insurance, and the costs of buying and selling. Compare the full picture over the years you expect to own. See the rent-versus-buy example.

03What if my parents lost their home in 2008 and I’m afraid to buy?

That experience deserves a real conversation. Start by identifying what worries you: losing income, a payment increase, falling prices, or not having savings for repairs. Then look at the loan terms, the full payment, your reserves, and a realistic plan if life changes. You can explore your options without committing to buy. Read about family experiences and homebuying fears.

04Do I need a 20% down payment to buy my first home?

No. Some eligible buyers can use conventional financing with as little as 3% down, while FHA financing can allow 3.5% down. With down payment assistance such as CalHFA MyHome, eligible buyers may cover part or all of the required down payment and bring less of their own money than the down payment amount. Closing costs, prepaid expenses, and any remaining funds still need to be accounted for; assistance, seller credits, and program rules determine your actual cash to close. MyHome is a repayable loan with deferred payments. Compare the cash needed upfront and the full monthly payment together. Explore conventional loans and FHA loans.

05What should I include in my monthly house payment?

Include principal and interest, property taxes, homeowners insurance, and any mortgage insurance. Add HOA dues or other required assessments where applicable, even if they are paid separately. Keep room in your spending plan for repairs, utilities, and savings too. See the full-payment chart and build your home budget.

06What if I earn too much for HomeReady or Home Possible?

Being above a program’s income limit does not mean you cannot get a mortgage. Compare other conventional options, FHA, and any CalHFA program whose county income limit you meet. Some other first-time-buyer pricing benefits may also apply. The right comparison uses actual rates, mortgage insurance, fees, and your full payment. Start with HomeReady, conventional loan options, and CalHFA assistance.

07Is down payment assistance free money, or do I repay it?

It depends on the program. CalHFA MyHome is an interest-bearing loan with deferred payments; repayment is due under its terms, including sale or refinance. Dream For All requires repayment of the assistance plus a share of appreciation under its rules. Other programs may offer grants or forgivable loans. Read the terms for the specific help you are considering. Compare CalHFA assistance and Dream For All.

08Can the seller pay my closing costs if I use assistance?

A seller can agree to a credit toward eligible closing costs. FHA generally allows interested-party contributions up to 6% of the sales price. For the low-down-payment conventional primary-home loans discussed here, the limit is generally 3% of the lower of price or appraised value when loan-to-value exceeds 90%. Credits cannot exceed eligible actual costs or replace the required down payment. See how MyHome and seller credits can work together.

09Can I buy a home with my parents or another family member?

Buying together can help some families combine income or resources, but it also creates shared obligations. Before committing, decide who will live there, who owns what share, who pays each expense, and what happens if someone wants to leave or cannot pay. Loan and assistance rules differ, including rules for borrowers who will not occupy the home. Explore buying a home with family.

10How do I find out what I can qualify for and whether buying makes sense?

Start with a conversation about your income, savings, debts, credit, goals, and a payment you could live with comfortably. Amy can help you identify options and the next steps toward a lender’s review. The free 30-minute discovery call is a starting point, not a loan approval or a commitment to buy. Book your free 30-minute discovery call.