Roseville, CA · NMLS 281056 · Licensed CA, TN, TX (916) 705-2557 adebusk@loandepot.com

Back to the research

Restoring the American Dream

The findings worth talking about

A closer look at housing supply, loan pricing, and the opportunity to own a home.

Report page 3A

The findings worth talking about

How did we get here? Why are homes scarce, and why do some aspiring buyers hesitate? This paper connects underbuilding, limited listings, affordability and the experiences that shape confidence.

The goal is sustainable ownership: stability, control and the opportunity to build equity, with a payment and spending plan a family can maintain. This guide highlights the evidence and its limits.

The crash left a shortage that outlasted the foreclosures

Housing starts fell from about 2.07 million in 2005 to 554,000 in 2009. Builders, workers and financing did not return overnight. Freddie Mac estimated a 3.7-million-unit national shortage in late 2024. The shortage is not just a lack of buildings: families need homes in the right places at prices they can afford. See pages 8-15 and Appendix A.

The golden handcuffs of a low mortgage rate

Homeowners with mortgage rates in the 2% or 3% range may want to move as their needs change. But replacing that low-cost loan can mean a much larger payment, even for a similar home. Their valuable low rate can make moving unaffordable or unattractive: the golden handcuffs of homeownership.

When owners stay instead of selling, fewer homes become available, including starter homes for first-time buyers. This does not remove physical homes, but it worsens the shortage of listings. FHFA estimated that rate lock-in prevented about 1.72 million sales from 2022 Q2 through 2024 Q2. [2]

Could owners take their rate to their next home? The proposed Take Your Rate Act of 2026 (H.R. 7754) would require HUD and FHFA to study that idea for federally backed mortgages. It is a study proposal, not a law granting portability. Costs, investor rights and loan rules still need answers. See pages 16-27 and references [3, 39].

A large assistance offer may still leave a family unable to buy

Placer County reported 109 processed applications but 13 fully approved households in February 2026. That is not a final denial or closing rate. It illustrates why eligibility, enough money for the down payment and closing costs, an affordable monthly payment, and a suitable home must line up. Down payment assistance programs cannot solve every barrier on their own. See pages 32-35.

The memory of losing a home can travel to the next generation

Research links parental mortgage distress with lower subsequent homeownership among children, and close experience of housing losses with lower confidence among younger survey respondents. Amy hears these concerns in her own client conversations. The evidence does not measure how many qualified buyers today are held back by fear, but it gives us a reason to listen. See pages 40-41 and the new continuation, 41A-41E.

Report page 3B

Loan pricing and the cost of opportunity

Loan-level pricing adjustments can feel like a tax on access to credit

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac apply upfront loan-level pricing adjustments or credit fees to certain conventional mortgages. They can be reflected in points, the interest rate or lender credits. They are not literal taxes or charges on every mortgage. Eligible borrowers and programs may receive waivers. [7, 82, 83]

In my view, these charges can feel like a tax on the opportunity to become a homeowner. Families with less savings or lower credit scores may face higher borrowing costs just when affordability is already difficult. The report illustrates a $4,500 difference between selected credit-score pricing cells on a $400,000 loan, before waivers and other features. See pages 36-37.

Fee relief for eligible buyers and recent pricing changes are steps forward. For example, Fannie Mae aligned pricing across Classic FICO and VantageScore 4.0 in October 2026; that is not a blanket fee cut. [8] I welcome progress, but believe it is not enough. We should examine whether remaining charges and income cutoffs unnecessarily hold back sustainable homeownership.

These adjustments sit within a guarantee-fee system generating billions in revenue. But total guarantee-fee revenue also includes ongoing fees and is not a measure of LLPA collections alone. The fees support credit guarantees, administration and capital; they are not simply government profit. [82, 103]

FHA insurance costs deserve a transparent affordability review

The report compares the strength of FHA's insurance fund with the room a responsible premium reduction could create in a family's spending plan. A hypothetical 0.20-percentage-point annual premium reduction on a $400,000 balance is about $66.67 a month. This is a policy illustration, not an announced benefit or proof that reserves can simply be paid out. See pages 37A-37C.

Report page 3C

Homeownership can create opportunity

Principal repayment can build equity, and a fixed-rate mortgage can stabilize principal and interest. But maintenance, insurance, taxes, time in the home and price changes matter. The paper's rent-versus-buy model even shows renting and investing ahead for some holding periods and assumptions. Honest education makes the case for ownership stronger by explaining when it fits, not by promising wealth. See pages 28-31.

What should we do about it

Build more attainable homes, not just approve more units on paper. Design down payment assistance programs around real purchase prices, full monthly costs and enough money for the down payment and closing costs. Explain repayment obligations and whether funding is actually available. Test pricing and mobility reforms with clear costs and protections. See pages 10-15, 19-26, 32-37 and 46-47.

Education belongs in that solution. Show families what changed after 2008, explain the loan they are considering, and make room for their questions. Pair the opportunity to build equity with a realistic spending plan, repair reserves and a clear exit plan. Measure success in sustainable ownership, not just applications or approvals.

Continue with Chapter 1